Roofing Guides

Which roof should I choose in South Florida: tile, metal or shingle?

Updated November 20, 2026 Reviewed by Brandon Vega, owner, Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. (license CCC1336242)
Gray standing seam metal roof on a South Florida home
Photo: Apex Roofing Solutions

Choose architectural shingle if your first priority is a lower upfront price. Choose concrete tile if you want to keep the look of a tile roof. Choose 24 gauge standing seam metal if you like the look of raised metal seams and the written price fits your budget. What makes sense for your home depends on which systems fit it and whether the roof needs replacing at all. We’re Apex Roofing Solutions Corp., a licensed and insured roofing contractor in Miami Lakes serving Miami-Dade and Broward. Book a free roof inspection and we’ll give you a written price with every fee listed and payments tied to permit approval and the city inspections.

Key takeaways

  • As of November 11, 2026, Apex's installed planning range for architectural shingle is $6 to $7.50 per square foot. Concrete tile is $9.75 to $11 per square foot. For 24 gauge standing seam, it’s $11 to $13 per square foot. What’s on the roof now and the underlayment affect your price. So do the system and the complexity of your roof.
  • Use the same roof surface area to compare each option. One roofing square is 100 square feet.
  • Ask which Miami-Dade Notice of Acceptance applies to the roof your roofer is proposing. Have them show you where the written proposal names the underlayment.
  • After we inspect your roof, Apex can show you up to 3 replacement options, starting with the lowest price.
  • Apex charges $500 when you sign. You pay 35% of the balance when the permit is approved. Another 35% is due when the inspection during installation passes. The final 30% is due when the final inspection passes.

How far apart are the prices for all three on the same house?

Architectural shingle has the lowest upfront planning range of the three. As of November 11, 2026, the installed rate for architectural shingle was $6 to $7.50 per square foot. Concrete tile was $9.75 to $11 per square foot. For 24 gauge standing seam metal, it was $11 to $13 per square foot. What’s on your roof now affects the price. So does the underlayment, which is the layer beneath the finished roof covering. The exact system you choose and how complicated your roof is affect the price too.

Let’s say your roof measures 22 squares. A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof surface, so you’re looking at 2,200 square feet of roof. Use the roof measurement on your estimate. The square footage of your house measures a different area. At those rates, you’d budget $13,200 to $16,500 for architectural shingle. For concrete tile, you’d budget $21,450 to $24,200. For 24 gauge standing seam metal, you’d budget $24,200 to $28,600.

Those totals let you compare materials for the same roof size. In that example, tile tops out where metal starts, at $24,200. So if you like both, get a price for both. On your house, each option can land in a different part of its range. Once you have written proposals for the same roof, subtract one total from the other. Then ask the roofer to show you what changes in the work.

When are architectural shingles a good fit for a South Florida home?

Choose architectural shingles if keeping the upfront price down matters most to you and the proposed system fits your house. As of November 11, 2026, the installed range of $6 to $7.50 per square foot gives you a place to start with your budget. The roof you have now and the underlayment can move the price. The specific shingle system and the shape of your roof can also move it.

Ask the roofer to show you where the bid names the shingle and the layer beneath it. The deck is the wood surface beneath the roofing. Underlayment goes over that wood before the finished roof covering goes on. If the bid just says architectural shingle, ask for the product name and the underlayment so you know what you’re paying for.

If you’re going from tile or metal to shingles, make sure everyone making the decision has seen how shingles would look on your house. Look at a sample from the driveway. Then think about how much of the roof you can see from the street. If you like how it looks and the work in the proposal fits your house, you have a shingle price you can compare with the other two.

When does it make sense to go with concrete tile again?

Go with concrete tile if the tile shape is part of what you like about the house and the proposed system fits it. If you already have tile, start by getting a written price for new concrete tile. If you have shingles now, first ask your roofer to confirm whether the structure can support the proposed tile roof.

Look at the color and the tile profile, which is the shape you see when you look at the tile from the end. Ask the roofer which exact tile they’ll use and how they’ll secure it. Then have them show you where the proposal names the underlayment. You can choose a tile for how it looks and still ask what goes underneath, where you won’t see it once the roof is finished.

If the tile quote includes an underlayment upgrade, ask the roofer to show you the product name and the dollar difference on the proposal. If you also like standing seam, get a metal price for the same roof before you decide whether to spend that money on the tile option. Compare two proposals you’d actually be willing to sign.

When is it worth getting a price for standing seam metal?

Get a price for 24 gauge standing seam if you like the look of raised seams and you’re already considering concrete tile. Standing seam means the joints where the metal panels meet are raised. I’m Brandon Vega, and standing seam is my personal pick. For your house, look at the exact panel in the proposal, how the roofer plans to install it and what you’d pay.

If the estimate just says metal, ask which panel the roofer would use. Ask for the gauge, which describes the thickness of the metal. Then ask how they’ll attach it. As of November 11, 2026, the installed planning range of $11 to $13 per square foot is for 24 gauge standing seam. What’s on the roof now and the underlayment affect where the price lands. So do the particular system and the complexity of the roof.

If the standing seam and tile bids come back close, look at a sample of each. Then have the roofer go over both written warranties with you. Ask which products they cover and what installation specifications apply. If the bids are far enough apart to matter to you, use the two written totals to decide what the metal option is worth to you.

What should your roofer check before you pick a material?

Find out which systems fit your house before you pick a material or color. Ask the roofer how the system fits the slope, or how steep the roof is. Ask how it fits the surface it will attach to. Then ask how it fits the wind pressure your roof is designed for. If your neighborhood has an association, ask the association directly about written roofing restrictions before choosing a different material or profile.

Ask for the Miami-Dade Notice of Acceptance, or NOA, for the proposed system. A Notice of Acceptance is a product approval document. Have the roofer show you which parts apply to your house and how they match the way they plan to install the roof. The underlayment document tells you about that product. Ask how it fits into the full roof system the roofer is pricing.

Miami-Dade's Product Approval Notices explain that the ninth edition of the Florida Building Code takes effect December 31, 2026. The county says the changes affect some existing roofing underlayment approvals. The county also says the changes affect how the shingles that cover ridges and outside roof corners must be tested and attached. If your project is moving forward around that date, ask which approval and installation details the roofer plans to use for your permit.

How do you know if it’s time to choose a new roof material?

Start with the roof you have and see what shape it’s in. At Apex, we get up on the roof and take photos. Then we show you what needs attention and what only affects how the roof looks. If a repair makes sense for the work needed and the useful life the roof has left, we’ll quote the repair. If replacement makes more sense, we’ll show you up to three options that fit your house side by side, starting with the lowest price.

Ask your roofer to show you what they saw that led to the recommendation. If you called about a leak, ask how what they found relates to where you saw water inside. Then ask whether the proposed repair addresses that area. If the roofer recommends replacement, ask what shape the rest of the roof is in and what they found that makes a repair a poor use of your money. That gives you a reason to choose between fixing the roof you have and buying a new one.

How do you pay Apex for each roof option?

We use the same payment schedule for every Apex residential replacement. You pay $500 when you sign. Once the city approves the permit, you pay 35% of the remaining balance. Another 35% of the balance is due when the inspection during installation passes. The last 30% is due when the final inspection passes. Financing is available, and we show the monthly amount on your quote. Your quoted price holds for 30 days.

Before work starts, we put every price and term in the proposal. We list every fee, including the permit fees. For each replacement, we take the old roof off down to the wood deck. We install the new system with the underlayment named in your proposal. We also handle the permit and both city inspections. Ask for the written scope for each material so you can see what changes in the roof itself when you go from one option to the next.

If you’re worried about what the bill will look like once the old roof comes off, look at how the contract prices that work. It prices rotten deck wood by the sheet. It prices fascia or soffit by the foot. Fascia is the trim along the roof edge. Soffit is the underside of the roof overhang. We charge for the quantities we actually replace. Ask where those prices are written and how we’ll show you the quantities when the work is done.

We give you a 10-year workmanship warranty in writing. You also get the manufacturer warranty where the system has one and we install the roof to its specifications. Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. is licensed and insured under Florida license CCC1336242. If you’d like help figuring out which options fit your home in Miami-Dade or Broward, call 305-290-2482 to book a free roof inspection.

Questions homeowners ask

Can I go from shingles to concrete tile?

Before you budget for a concrete tile roof, ask your roofer to confirm whether your house can support the proposed roof. Ask what they need to check. Then ask what work, if any, they would have to add to the proposal.

Is it worth pricing metal if I like the look of tile?

Yes, if you’d be happy with either look. Apex's November 11, 2026 installed planning ranges were $9.75 to $11 per square foot for concrete tile and $11 to $13 for 24 gauge standing seam metal. What’s on your roof now matters. So does the underlayment, the layer beneath the roof covering. The system and the complexity of your roof also affect both prices. Get both prices in writing for your house so you can see what you’d actually pay for the difference.

Does Apex give you the same workmanship warranty on all three options?

Yes. We give you a 10-year written workmanship warranty on residential replacements. That applies to architectural shingle. It also applies to concrete tile. Standing seam metal gets the same workmanship warranty. We include the manufacturer warranty where the system has one. It applies when we install the roof to the manufacturer’s specifications. Ask to see the terms for the exact system you’re considering.

What do I pay Apex before and after the inspections?

On a residential replacement, we collect $500 when you sign. You pay 35% of the balance when the city approves the permit. You pay another 35% when the inspection during installation passes. The last 30% is due when the final inspection passes. If you’re considering financing, you’ll see the monthly payment on your quote.

Sources

Free Estimate

Tell Us About Your Roof

Share a few details and our team will follow up with the next step.

  • Roof repairs, replacements, and inspections
  • Tile, shingle, metal, and commercial roofing
  • Serving Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Monroe counties

Prefer to talk to a person?

Call now if you need help today.

305-290-2482