Roofing Guides

Why are roof quotes so different in South Florida?

Updated November 15, 2026 Reviewed by Brandon Vega, owner, Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. (license CCC1336242)
Apex Roofing Solutions crew tearing off an old roof to the wood deck while Polyglass underlayment goes down
Photo: Apex Roofing Solutions

Roof replacement quotes in South Florida can differ because the roof systems are different, the included work is different or some costs sit outside the total. Start with the written scope and compare it line by line. Then compare the price. At Apex Roofing Solutions Corp., we offer a free inspection. We put every fee in writing and tie payments to permit approval and passed city inspections. However, comparing paperwork cannot tell you your roof's condition or reveal all the wood that may need replacing after tear-off.

Key takeaways

  • Use 8 checks: measured area and removal scope; roof system; underlayment; product approvals; wood charges; permit and inspections; warranties; payment terms.
  • FRSA explains that a product's performance and limitations of use must be compared with the project's design requirements.
  • Apex's November 11, 2026, installed going-rate ranges are $6 to $7.50 per square foot for architectural shingle. Concrete tile is $9.75 to $11, and 24 gauge standing seam metal is $11 to $13. These are not quotes. Underlayment and the existing roof move the price. The chosen system and roof complexity move it too.
  • Apex takes $500 at signing. Then you pay 35% of the balance at permit approval, 35% after the in-progress inspection passes and 30% after the final inspection passes.
  • Florida DBPR lets you search a contractor by license number or name. Apex's license is CCC1336242.

What are the 8 checks for comparing roof quotes?

Put every proposal on the same comparison sheet first. The total only helps when you know what you are getting for it. Make the following eight checks your rows and give each contractor a column. Write down the actual terms. Simply checking that an item is mentioned does not give you those terms.

1. Measured area and removal scope: What roof area is priced? Which portions are included? How much existing roofing will be removed?

2. Roof system: What covering and exact system will go back on the house?

3. Underlayment: Which manufacturer and product are specified beneath the covering? What layer arrangement is specified?

4. Product approvals: Which approval documents identify the proposed products and system? How do they fit this project's design requirements?

5. Wood charges: What wood is included? What are the unit prices? How will additional replacement be documented?

6. Permit and inspections: Who handles them? What permit fees are included or listed separately?

7. Warranties: What does the contractor promise in writing? What separate manufacturer warranty applies?

8. Payment terms: What is due at signing? What triggers later payments? How long does the quoted price hold?

If a proposal is incomplete, ask for these same eight items. A blank does not prove the contractor excluded the work. It means you do not yet have enough information to compare that part of the offer. Get the answer in the revised proposal before you sign.

Can two proposals describe different jobs on the same house?

Yes. Contractors can quote different materials or include different amounts of work on the same roof. Ask what changed between the proposals. Start with the measured area and removal scope, then go through the remaining checks. Do not assume the whole price gap is labor or profit.

In a July 2025 Reddit thread, a South Florida homeowner posted four reroofing proposals for approximately 1,800 square feet of pitched roof and 600 square feet of flat roof. The proposals described different underlayments. Their wood allowances differed too. Two listed permit charges outside the stated total.

That homeowner's comparison shows what a single total can leave unanswered. If a proposal covers pitched and flat portions, you need enough detail to identify the work on each portion. If it includes a wood allowance, you also need to know what happens when replacement goes beyond that allowance.

Those Reddit bids are reports from one homeowner. They are not current market rates or proof that a particular contractor offered better work. Use the thread to help you ask better questions, then base your decision on the written scope for your own house.

At Apex, residential replacement includes a full tear-off to the wood deck. We get on the roof and show you your own photos. We separate what needs fixing from what is cosmetic. If you are uncertain whether replacement is needed at all, that inspection comes before choosing a replacement system.

Why do the underlayment and approval documents matter?

You are buying more than the covering you can see. Underlayment is the material beneath that covering, and the proposal should name its manufacturer and product. A phrase like 'quality underlayment' does not tell you what you are getting. Ask how many layers are proposed and which roof system they belong to.

Think of a kitchen remodel proposal that gives you the countertop color but never names the countertop material. You know what it is supposed to look like, but you cannot compare what you are buying. You need that same clarity about the roofing materials beneath the visible surface.

The Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association, or FRSA, explains that Florida Product Approvals concern products and components. Miami-Dade Notices of Acceptance, or NOAs, concern an approved system. Ask the contractor to identify the applicable documents. Do not accept 'installed to code' as the complete description.

FRSA also explains that project-specific use of a product depends on its performance and limitations of use compared with the design requirements for the project. Its example is required roofing design pressure based on the Florida Building Code wind speed map. Ask: 'Can you show me how this product's approval meets my roof's design requirements?'

FRSA's explanation was published February 27, 2018. It explains how the approvals differ, but it does not establish that a particular proposal meets today's requirements. Have the contractor identify the approval documents that apply to your project. Then have them explain the proposed installation against those documents.

How do I compare wood allowances without guessing the final bill?

Start by separating the included amount from the price of additional replacement. An allowance tells you how much wood is included in the proposal. A unit price tells you what another sheet or foot will cost. You need both when you compare a proposal with an allowance against one without it.

The possibility of a larger bill after tear-off is a real concern. So get the charges in writing before removal starts. At Apex, rotten wood deck is priced per sheet in the contract. Fascia and soffit are priced per foot. We charge only for what is actually replaced.

The deck is the wood surface beneath the roofing. Fascia is the board along the roof edge. Soffit is the underside of the overhang. Keep those descriptions separate when you compare, because a price for a sheet of deck does not tell you the price for a foot of fascia.

Ask each contractor what evidence you will receive for additional replacement and how you will review it. Also ask how you will authorize additional work. A generous allowance does not answer the whole question if the proposal says nothing about charges beyond it.

A written unit price does not tell you the final quantity before tear-off. It tells you how the charge is calculated once that quantity is established. That is the difference between an honest unknown and an extra charge nobody explained.

What price ranges can I use to check my comparison?

Use a range for context after you match the scope. It does not replace an inspection. Apex's installed residential going rates as of November 11, 2026, are $6 to $7.50 per square foot for architectural shingle. Concrete tile is $9.75 to $11. Our 24 gauge standing seam metal range is $11 to $13.

These are going-rate ranges, not quotes. Underlayment changes the price. The roof you have now matters too. The selected system and roof complexity also affect the price. Ask the contractor to explain where your proposed job falls within its written scope.

Let's say the measured roof is 20 squares. One roofing square equals 100 square feet of roof, so this example uses 2,000 square feet of roof area. That is the roof area, not the house's floor area.

Multiply that stated area by Apex's ranges and you get $12,000 to $15,000 for architectural shingle. The concrete tile calculation is $19,500 to $22,000. For 24 gauge standing seam metal, it is $22,000 to $26,000. These are arithmetic examples using the November 11 ranges, not offers for a particular home.

That calculation does not settle unknown wood quantities or replace the permit fee listed in a contract. It also does not establish which system fits your house. For a written price based on your roof, book a free roof inspection with Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. at 305-290-2482.

How does Apex put the price and payment schedule in writing?

For a residential replacement, we start with an on-roof inspection and a written proposal. Every price is written before work begins. Every fee and term is written too. Your contract lists permit fees and the unit prices for wood that may need replacing. Financing is available, with the monthly number shown on the quote.

You pay a $500 deposit at signing. We divide the remaining balance into three payments. You pay 35% when the city approves the permit, 35% after the in-progress inspection passes and 30% after the final inspection passes. Those percentages apply to the balance after the deposit. They are not an additional amount beyond the contract price.

We handle the permit and both city inspections. The permit timeline is about 2 to 4 weeks after signing, followed by a firm install date. A quoted price holds for 30 days, so you have a clear expiration date while you compare the written options.

Ask what event triggers each payment when you compare another proposal. 'During the job' is less specific than naming the passed inspection. Put the payment terms beside the scope. That way, you can see what you must pay before each stage is complete.

The total matters, and so does when you must hand over the money. We connect payments to permit approval and passed inspections because that gives you named milestones to follow.

What should I check about warranties and the contractor?

Read the contractor's workmanship warranty separately from the manufacturer's warranty. At Apex, residential replacement includes a written 10-year workmanship warranty, plus the manufacturer warranty where the system has one. Manufacturer warranties hold only when the roof is installed to the manufacturer's specifications. Ask to see the actual terms.

A large warranty number alone does not tell you who is responsible for a problem. Ask which document addresses installation work. Then ask which document addresses the manufactured materials. Keep each document with its proposal so you do not compare different promises as though they were the same.

Check the contractor's business and license information against the proposal. Florida's Department of Business and Professional Regulation provides an online search by license number or name. Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. is licensed and insured, with Florida Certified Roofing Contractor license CCC1336242.

Also ask who handles the permit and how you will receive the final inspection record. If you are concerned about accountability after someone receives your deposit, start with the named contracting business. Review its written obligations. Then review the payment milestones.

A clear document does not answer every question about a contractor. It does give you specific promises to review and specific gaps to resolve before you commit.

What should I send the roofers before choosing a proposal?

Send every contractor the same request for the eight comparison items. Ask for a revised written proposal so important answers do not stay in a phone conversation. Once the missing details are filled in, you can see whether the price difference comes with different work or different terms.

You can write: 'Please confirm these eight items in your proposal: 1. Measured area and removal scope. 2. Roof system. 3. Underlayment. 4. Product approvals. 5. Wood charges. 6. Permit and inspections. 7. Warranties. 8. Payment terms. Please explain any exclusions and identify what accounts for the price difference from the other scope I am comparing.'

If a contractor proposes a different material, ask why it fits your roof and budget. You do not have to choose the same covering just to make the totals look comparable. You do need to understand what changes with each option before you decide whether that difference is worth paying.

Before you settle on a material, settle whether you need replacement. At Apex, the on-roof inspection decides. If a repair fixes the problem for less than the roof has left to give, we quote the repair. Otherwise, we can show replacement options in up to three systems side by side.

For homeowners in Miami-Dade and Broward, we are happy to walk through the photos and written options so you can make an informed decision. Book a free inspection with no obligation, or call 305-290-2482. You should finish the comparison knowing what you are buying and when you will pay.

Questions homeowners ask

Does a higher roof quote mean I am getting a better roof?

The total alone does not tell you that. Ask the contractor to explain what accounts for the difference. Start with the named roof system and underlayment. Then check the approval documents. Check the included work and written terms too. If those details are blank on one proposal, get the missing information before you choose.

Can I compare roofing prices using my home's square footage?

Use the measured roof area. One roofing square equals 100 square feet of roof, not the floor area of your house. Ask each contractor what roof area the proposal covers. Also ask whether every pitched and flat portion is included. You need the same measured scope to compare the prices.

Does a Miami-Dade NOA prove a product fits my roof?

An NOA, or Notice of Acceptance, identifies an approved system, according to the Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association. FRSA also explains that project-specific use of a product depends on its performance and limitations of use compared with the project's design requirements. So ask the contractor to show how the proposed product meets those requirements, including the required design pressure.

What should a proposal say about rotten wood?

It should tell you what allowance is included and how replacement beyond that allowance is charged. At Apex, rotten wood deck is priced per sheet in the contract. Fascia and soffit are priced per foot. We charge only for what is actually replaced. The quantity can remain unknown until the old roof comes off, but you have the unit prices in writing before work starts.

Are workmanship and manufacturer warranties the same?

You need to compare each warranty separately. At Apex, residential roof replacement includes a written 10-year workmanship warranty, plus the manufacturer warranty where the system has one. Manufacturer warranties hold only when the roof is installed to the manufacturer's specifications. Ask to read the written terms instead of comparing only the number of years.

What does Apex charge, and when do I pay?

We price each job after the inspection. Our installed going rates as of November 11, 2026, are $6 to $7.50 per square foot for architectural shingle. Concrete tile is $9.75 to $11, and 24 gauge standing seam metal is $11 to $13. These are ranges, not quotes. Underlayment and the existing roof move the price. The chosen system and roof complexity move it too. For a home, you pay $500 at signing. Then you pay 35% of the balance at city permit approval, 35% after the in-progress inspection passes and 30% after the final inspection passes.

Sources

Free Estimate

Tell Us About Your Roof

Share a few details and our team will follow up with the next step.

  • Roof repairs, replacements, and inspections
  • Tile, shingle, metal, and commercial roofing
  • Serving Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Monroe counties

Prefer to talk to a person?

Call now if you need help today.

305-290-2482