South Florida Roofing News

Citizens comparable coverage: what does roof replacement cost mean for homeowners in Miami-Dade and Broward?

Updated November 16, 2026 Reviewed by Brandon Vega, owner, Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. (license CCC1336242)
Newly installed dark asphalt shingle roof with ridge cap on a South Florida home
Photo: Apex Roofing Solutions

A competing Clearinghouse quote needs both roof replacement cost value for roof loss settlement and at least $10,000 in non-weather water damage coverage to qualify as comparable for CIT HO-3 and CIT DP-3 policies, according to Citizens' June 11, 2026 bulletin. Effective June 26, a quote missing either condition cannot make a homeowner ineligible for Citizens based on price. That rule compares quotes; it is not a promise about an individual roof claim payment. Citizens also warns that its historical bulletins may not reflect later changes. In Miami-Dade and Broward, we at Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. offer a free roof inspection with your own photos. We put the price and every fee in writing. Residential payments are tied to permit approval and city inspections.

Key takeaways

  • Citizens' June 11, 2026 bulletin requires both roof replacement cost value and at least $10,000 in non-weather water damage coverage for comparable quotes.
  • The June 26 change names CIT HO-3 and CIT DP-3 policies for both new business and renewals through the Clearinghouse.
  • Citizens says an offer classified as not comparable may still be presented, but cannot make the property ineligible based on price.
  • Ask your agent to verify the current requirements because Citizens warns that historical bulletins may not reflect later changes.
  • At Apex, we offer a free roof inspection with your own roof photos and a 10-year workmanship warranty in writing on residential replacement.

What changed in Citizens' June 26 quote comparison?

A competing carrier has to meet two added conditions under Citizens' comparable-coverage test for the policy types named in its June 11, 2026 bulletin. It must offer replacement cost value, abbreviated RCV, for roof loss settlement. It must also provide at least $10,000 in non-weather water damage coverage.

The change took effect June 26, 2026, for new business and renewal policies placed through the Clearinghouse Powered by EZLynx. Insurance Journal reported the clarification that same day.

The question is whether a lower-priced offer can affect whether you can stay with Citizens. The bulletin says that if either condition is missing, the quote is classified as not comparable and cannot make the property ineligible with Citizens based on price. The offer can still be presented. That limit on price-based ineligibility is the specific protection the announcement describes.

Which policy forms does this roof settlement test cover?

Check your policy form before applying this announcement to a competing quote. The bulletin applies the automated comparison to Citizens Homeowners 3 Special Form, identified as CIT HO-3, and Dwelling Property 3 Special Form, identified as CIT DP-3 Dwelling. Ask your insurance agent to identify which form you have.

Do not assume the process is the same for every Citizens policy. The June bulletin separately lists HO-6 unit-owner policies and DP-1 basic dwelling policies under a coming-soon heading. It also gives instructions for agents seeking an override in specified circumstances.

There is a date limit here too. Citizens labels its online agent communications as historical and says they are not updated for later changes. So ask your agent to check the current underwriting information for your transaction instead of relying on the June bulletin alone.

What should you ask about how a roof loss is settled?

Ask your insurance agent to show you the written roof loss settlement provision in each offer. Have the agent explain whether it offers the replacement cost value required by the Citizens comparison. Then ask the agent or insurer how that wording would apply to a roof loss under that particular policy.

Comparing a quote and calculating a claim payment are separate questions. Meeting Citizens' stated comparison conditions does not, by itself, tell you the amount of an individual claim payment. Neither the Citizens bulletin nor Insurance Journal's report calculates what a homeowner would receive for a damaged roof.

Ask this directly: "Where does this offer state how roof damage is valued, and what could I have to pay myself?" Get the explanation in writing. If you are reviewing an actual loss, ask the insurer to explain the deductible and the settlement calculation. At Apex, we explain the roofing paper trail. Your insurer or insurance agent answers coverage questions. We do not advise on coverage or adjust claims.

How can roof photos and an estimate help keep the questions separate?

At Apex, we can document the roof's condition and price the roofing work. Your insurance professional addresses the policy questions. Written roofing findings give you a concrete description of the work to discuss, but a contractor's estimate is not an insurance payment decision.

We get on the roof and show you your own photos. Then we separate what needs fixing from what is cosmetic. That inspection guides our recommendation. If a repair fixes the problem for less than the roof has left to give, we quote the repair. Otherwise, we quote replacement options.

For an insurance claim, we work alongside your licensed public adjuster and supply the inspection report and roofing estimate. Hiring a public adjuster is your choice. We do the roof once the claim is settled.

If you need to understand the roof's condition before deciding on work, book a free roof inspection or call 305-290-2482. There is no obligation.

How does Apex put the roof price and payment stages in writing?

We price residential replacement after the inspection. Before work starts, we put every price, fee and term in writing. The contract requires a $500 deposit at signing. You then pay 35% of the balance when the city approves the permit, 35% after the in-progress inspection passes, and 30% after the final inspection passes.

The concern is what happens to the bill after tear-off. Here is how we put those charges in the contract: rotten wood deck is priced per sheet. Fascia and soffit are priced per foot, and charges apply only to what is actually replaced. Permit fees are listed in the contract too.

Financing is available, with the monthly payment shown on the quote. A quoted price holds for 30 days. Residential replacement includes a 10-year workmanship warranty in writing, plus the manufacturer warranty where the system has one. Manufacturer warranties depend on installation to the manufacturer's specifications.

Those written roofing terms show you your construction payment obligations while your insurance professional explains the insurance side.

What should you get answered before deciding your next step?

First, confirm your policy form with your insurance agent. Then request the written roof settlement provision in the competing offer. Also ask the agent to verify the non-weather water damage limit and the current Citizens comparison requirements.

If you are considering roofing work, get a separate written recommendation based on the roof itself. Comparing insurance quotes does not replace an on-roof inspection. The June announcement does not establish that your home needs a replacement.

We at Apex Roofing Solutions Corp. serve Miami-Dade and Broward from Miami Lakes and are licensed and insured under Florida roofing license CCC1336242. Call 305-290-2482 to book a free roof inspection. We will show you what we found and put the recommended work and price in writing so you can make an informed decision.

Questions homeowners ask

Does Citizens require both roof replacement cost settlement and the water coverage minimum?

Yes. Citizens requires both for the CIT HO-3 and CIT DP-3 quotes addressed in its June 11 bulletin: replacement cost value for roof loss settlement and at least $10,000 in non-weather water damage coverage. If either condition is missing, the quote is not comparable under that bulletin.

Can a quote classified as not comparable still appear?

Yes. Citizens says those offers will still be presented. Under this rule, though, they cannot make the homeowner ineligible for Citizens based on price. Ask your insurance agent to confirm how the current requirements apply to your offer.

Does this announcement tell me what my roof claim will pay?

No. It sets the conditions for comparing certain Clearinghouse quotes. It does not calculate a payment for your roof. Ask your insurer to explain the roof loss settlement terms and any deductible in writing. We provide roofing findings and an estimate at Apex, but we do not advise on coverage or adjust claims.

What does Apex charge, and when do I pay?

We offer a free roof inspection with no obligation. We price roofing work per job after the inspection. Residential replacement requires $500 at signing, then 35% of the balance at city permit approval, 35% after the in-progress inspection passes, and 30% after the final inspection passes. Financing is available with the monthly amount shown on the quote.

Sources

Free Estimate

Tell Us About Your Roof

Share a few details and our team will follow up with the next step.

  • Roof repairs, replacements, and inspections
  • Tile, shingle, metal, and commercial roofing
  • Serving Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Monroe counties

Prefer to talk to a person?

Call now if you need help today.

305-290-2482